Walgreen Sued for Keeping Underperforming TDFs in 401(k)

Despite a market “teeming with better-performing alternatives,” the plaintiffs say, Walgreen selected the Northern Trust Funds, which already had a history of poor performance.

A group of current and former participants in the Walgreen Profit-Sharing Retirement Plan, individually and as representatives of a class of participants and beneficiaries of the plan, have filed a lawsuit on behalf of the plan for breach of fiduciary duties under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA).

The lawsuit names as defendants Walgreen Co., the Retirement Plan Committee For Walgreen Profit-Sharing Retirement Plan and its members, and the Trustees for the Walgreen Profit-Sharing Retirement Trust and its members.

Never miss a story — sign up for PLANADVISER newsletters to keep up on the latest retirement plan adviser news.

The complaint notes that as fiduciaries, the Walgreen defendants must prudently curate the plan’s investment options. They must regularly monitor plan investments and remove ones that become imprudent. The lawsuit alleges that the defendants breached these fiduciary duties by adding to the plan in 2013 a suite of poorly performing funds called the Northern Trust Focus Target Retirement Trusts and keeping these funds in the plan despite their continued underperformance.

Despite a market “teeming with better-performing alternatives,” the plaintiffs say, Walgreen selected the Northern Trust Funds, which already had a history of poor performance. According to the complaint, they had significantly underperformed their benchmark indexes and comparable target-date funds since Northern Trust launched the funds in 2010.

The lawsuit contends it was predictable that the Northern Trust Funds continued underperforming through the present. For nearly a decade, these investment options performed worse than 70% to 90% percent of peer funds, according to the complaint. The plaintiffs say not only does Walgreen refuse to remove the funds, it has actually added Northern Trust funds to the plan’s investment lineup, and selected the Northern Trust target-date funds as the plan’s default investment.

According to the complaint, the funds now comprise 11 of the 24 investment options in the plan and collectively hold more than $3 billion in plan assets, which represents more than 30% of the plan’s assets. “Walgreen’s imprudent decision to retain the Northern Trust Funds has had a large, tangible impact on participants’ retirement accounts. Based on an analysis of data compiled by Morningstar, Inc., Plaintiffs project the Plan lost upwards of $300 million in retirement savings since 2014 because of Walgreen’s decision to retain the Northern Trust Funds instead of removing them,” the complaint states.

It further says, “The Northern Trust Funds have also impaired the Plan’s overall performance. According to Brightscope, the average Plan participant could earn $193,925 less in retirement savings than employees in top-rated retirement plans of a similar size. The $193,925 disparity translates to an additional 10 years of work per participant.”

The plaintiffs are seeking to enforce the Walgreen defendants’ personal liability under ERISA to make good to the plan all losses resulting from each breach of fiduciary duty occurring during from January 1, 2014, to the date of judgment. In addition, they seek such other equitable or remedial relief for the plan as the court may deem appropriate.

Notably, given the impending U.S. Supreme Court decision in the case of Intel v. Sulyma regarding when “actual knowledge” actually starts for retirement plan participants for use in deciding when a case is filed beyond the statutory limits under ERISA, the Walgreen complaint says the plaintiffs did not have knowledge of all the material facts until shortly before they filed the complaint. “Further, Plaintiffs do not have actual knowledge of the specifics of the Walgreen Defendants’ decision-making processes with respect to the Plan, including the Walgreen Defendants’ processes for monitoring and removing Plan investments, because this information is solely within the possession of the Walgreen Defendants prior to discovery,” the complaint states.

Walgreen declined to comment on pending litigation.

Retirement Industry People Moves

Horizon Investments names head of portfolio management; FS Investments names chief technology and operations officer; and more.

Art by Subin Yang

Horizon Investments Names Head of PM

Horizon Investments has named Mike Dickson its new head of portfolio management. In his new role, Dickson will oversee all Horizon’s investment management strategies, including its goals-based portfolios and five mutual funds. Dickson previously served as director of structured financial solutions with Horizon.

Dickson speaks frequently at industry conferences, and his research is often published in scholarly journals. His most recent paper, “Combining Managed Money and Annuities: Improving Outcomes for Retirement Income Solutions,” appeared in the Q4 2018 issue of the Money Management Institute’s Journal of Investment Advisory Solutions.

For more stories like this, sign up for the PLANADVISERdash daily newsletter.

FS Investments Adds Chief Executive

FS Investments has hired Vincent Amatulli as chief technology and operations officer. Amatulli reports to Michael Forman, chairman and CEO of FS Investments, serves on the executive committee and is based in the firm’s Philadelphia headquarters.

Amatulli joins FS Investments from New York-based Broadridge Financial Solutions, where he served as the chief technology officer for the company’s global technology and operations division. In that role, he was responsible for the modernization and innovation of Broadridge’s technology platforms and the integration of company acquisitions into the firm’s technological architecture. 

Amatulli began his career as a programmer analyst at Goldman Sachs and spent nearly three decades with the firm, ultimately holding the position of executive vice president and chief information and operations officer.

Amatulli earned his undergraduate degree in computer science from Marist College and an MBA in international business from Pace University. 

Wilshire Phoenix Announces Partner in New Division

Mason Stark has been named a partner and head of Wilshire Phoenix Asset Management’s new alternative investments division.

Stark joins Wilshire Phoenix Asset Management with decades of experience as an equity analyst, trader and portfolio manager, focusing on managed hedged-equity and long/short portfolios.

Stark’s mandate is to help deliver alternative investment solutions that help institutional and private clients achieve their performance goals.

Drinker Biddle & Reath Continues ERISA Litigation Team Expansion

Drinker Biddle & Reath LLP announced that Kimberly Jones has joined the firm’s employee benefits and executive compensation group as a partner, based in its Chicago office. She comes to the firm from Ogletree Deakins.

Jones has represented clients in Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) and non-ERISA employee benefits matters at both the U.S. federal and state court levels. Her clients include insurance companies, employers, plan administrators, claim administrators, and multiemployer benefit funds. Jones has worked with these clients on a variety of benefit claim litigation matters, including disability, life, health, pension claim denials, and ERISA breach of fiduciary duty claims.

Jones has argued before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit and has represented clients in administrative employee benefits matters. She also provides counseling and guidance to clients regarding benefit claims and plan design.

Jones earned her J.D. degree from Chicago-Kent College of Law. She also holds a bachelor’s degree in journalism and communications from the University of Florida.

In addition to Jones, the firm added Gregory Ossi and Jason Luter earlier this year to its Employee Benefits and Executive Compensation Group. Based in Washington, D.C., Ossi’s practice is focused on multiemployer pension plan withdrawal matters, while Luter, residing in the firm’s Dallas office, has experience in ERISA, tax controversy and employment litigation matters.

«