Professional Advisers Ignoring Middle-Income Americans?

The Center for a Secure Retirement (CSR) found that 51% of middle-income Americans (annual income between $25,000 and $75,000) have not been approached or contacted by a professional adviser in the past 12 months.   

The survey also found that of middle-income Americans who do have a professional adviser, 84% made the initial contact.   

These findings from the “Middle-Income Retirement Preparedness Study” from the Bankers Life and Casualty Company Center for a Secure Retirement considered “professional advisers” to include a broad spectrum of people who can assist with retirement planning, including: financial planners, insurance agents, accountants, bank representatives, stock or mutual fund brokers, and lawyers.

Want the latest retirement plan adviser news and insights? Sign up for PLANADVISER newsletters.

Confidence levels among all middle-income Americans 

Participants in the study were pre-retirees or retirees between 55 and 75 years old.  Their confidence in adequacy of retirement savings varied substantially.  Thirty-seven percent said they are extremely or very confident with their retirement preparedness, 39% are somewhat confident, and 24% are not very confident or not confident at all.   

Feelings of confidence most commonly came from working with any kind of professional adviser (28%), having diversified retirement income sources (26%), carefully saving and planning throughout their working years (24%), living a simple lifestyle (18%), or not having any debt (11%). A lack of confidence was most commonly caused by a weak economy (24%), general uncertainty about future (17%), underperforming or no retirement accounts (12%), too little income (12%), or health concerns (9%).

Twenty-three percent of middle-income Americans surveyed by CSR said they never plan to retire and nearly half (47%) view retirement planning as complex and overwhelming.

The difference an adviser can make 

502 people participated in the study; 54% do not have a relationship with any kind of professional adviser, and 46% use the services of an adviser.   

Of the 54% who do not have an adviser, 84% said they don’t need one.  The top reasons for not needing an adviser were “I am capable of deciding for myself where and how to invest” (34%), “I do not have enough investable assets” (28%), and “It is too expensive/I can’t afford it” (23%).  Even though 34% of respondents without an adviser said they can take care of their investments themselves, 36% don’t spend any time doing research on retirement plan options.  Twenty-seven percent spend less than one hour a month, and 20% spend 1-3 hours a month.

The respondents who do not use an adviser use other sources of advice, however. Fifty-percent said they use the internet for advice, 38% use family or friends, and 35% use membership associations.

Of middle-income Americans age 55 to 75 who do not work with a professional adviser, 40% feel that a retirement planning professional would think their income is not large enough to need his or her products and services. Only 18% of those surveyed who do receive professional retirement planning advice share this concern.    

The 46% of middle-income Americans who use a professional adviser use all different kinds: 54% use a financial planner, 20% use a service representative at a financial firm, 6% use either a bank representative or stockbroker, and 4% use an accountant, mutual fund broker, or insurance agent/broker.

The average length of an adviser relationship is 11 years. Seventy-six percent of respondents are extremely or very satisfied with their adviser, 21% are somewhat satisfied, and 3% are not at all or not very satisfied.

The Internet-based survey was conducted in August 2010 by The Blackstone Group for the CSR.  Full details of the report can be seen here.   

 

«