Investing Public Feels Retirement Crisis is Real

The National Institute on Retirement Security’s (NIRS) sixth annual national retirement security poll shows many Americans would be willing to take lower salary increases in exchange for a pension benefit in retirement.

Nearly 75% of Americans are concerned about their ability to achieve a secure retirement, NIRS says, and support for steady and reliable retirement income from pensions and annuities is growing.

Some 82% of Americans say a pension is worth having because it provides steady income that won’t run out, while 67% indicate that they would be willing to take less in salary increases in exchange for more guaranteed income in retirement, according to the NIRS report “Retirement Security 2015: Roadmap for Policy Makers | Americans’ Views of the Retirement Crisis.”

Poll results also reveal that Americans feel their leaders in Washington don’t understand their struggle to save for retirement (cited by 87% of respondents), despite significant retirement-related regulatory and legislation action in recent years. Americans also generally want national policymakers to give more attention to retirement issues (84%). Regarding state-based efforts to improve retirement security, 71% of Americans agree that government-sponsored plans aimed at giving more private sector workers access to tax-advantaged retirement savings vehicles via payroll deductions are a good idea.

“The data evidence is irrefutable that the nation faces a retirement crisis,” says Diane Oakley, NIRS executive director. “This poll reveals that Americans understand the severity of crisis, and they want action and reform. We also learned how Americans plan to cope with retirement insecurity: 77% intend to cut back spending in retirement while 72% plan to stay in their current job as long as possible.”

These coping mechanisms clearly have broader implications, according to NIRS. “That is, older workers staying on the job crowds out younger workers, and decreased retiree spending has negative economic consequences,” Oakley explains. 

The research goes on to suggest that Americans see retirement benefits as a job feature that is almost as important as salary. Salary is viewed as important by 75% of Americans, while retirement benefits are close behind at 72%.

Also a telling result from the survey: Americans still express strong support for pensions for public employees. Some 87% of Americans say pensions are a good way to recruit and retain qualified teachers, police officers and firefighters. But, “only one-fourth of Americans understood that public employers pay for 25% or less of public pension costs,” NIRS claims, with the remainder being covered by employee contributions and investment returns.

Turning to the fraught topic of Social Security benefits, nearly three in four (73%) Americans say it is a mistake to cut government spending in such a way as to reduce Social Security benefits for current retirees, up from 67% in 2013. When it comes to benefits for future generations, 69% oppose cutting government spending that reduces Social Security benefits, NIRS says. Americans are divided when it comes to increasing the amount of Social Security benefits by delaying the withdrawal of benefits at an older age: 42% agree with a delay while 52% disagree.

Polling for the research was conducted by Greenwald & Associates as a nationwide telephone interview of 801 Americans age 25 or older. The data was balanced to reflect U.S. demographics for age, gender, and income. The margin of error is plus or minus 3.5%.

The full research results can be downloaded here.