Gen X, the First 401(k) Generation, Is Least Prepared for Retirement

Gen Xers entered the workforce as pensions were fading and 401(k) plans were ‘primitive.’ Now they are closest to retirement but feel least ready for it, according to Transamerica research.


Members of Generation X (born from 1965 through 1980) feel the least prepared for retirement of four working-age generations, according to a study released Thursday by the Transamerica Center for Retirement Studies and Transamerica Institute.

Part of that unease may be due to many members of that generation being close to, but not yet at, retirement age, according to the report. But researchers said another factor is that Gen Xers are the bridge generation between company-provided pensions and the 401(k) savings industry.

For more stories like this, sign up for the PLANADVISERdash daily newsletter.

“Generation X entered the workforce in the 1980s and 1990s as traditional pensions were fading from the retirement landscape and 401(k)s were in their infancy,” Catherine Collinson, CEO and president of Transamerica Institute and TCRS, wrote in the report. “In these early days of 401(k)s, relatively few employers offered them, plan features and services were primitive by today’s standards, and there was a widespread lack of awareness about the need to save. Consequentially, Generation X fell behind on their savings before they even knew it was time to get started.”

According to the research, which surveyed 5,725 employees, the median age when Gen X workers began saving for retirement was 30, as compared with Millennials (25), Gen Z (19). Baby Boomers, who were working in the age of pensions and very early 401(k) plans, started at a median age of 35.

Now only 17% of Gen Xers feel very confident they will be able to retire with a comfortable lifestyle, according to the study conducted in late 2022. In comparison, 27% of Millennials feel very confident in their retirement future, as do 23% of Gen Zers and 21% of Baby Boomers.

So Gen Xers clearly are not alone in their retirement anxiety. Transamerica researchers attributed some of the strain on retirement saving and outcomes to the pandemic and recent economic uncertainty. Furthermore, the researchers pointed out, other generations face their own unique problems.

Baby Boomers (born from 1946 through 1964) were already mid-career when defined contribution plans were introduced, and despite a mix of pensions and their own savings, nearly half (49%) expect to or already are working past age 70. That has made them “especially vulnerable to employment setbacks, volatility in the financial markets, and increasing inflation,” Collinson wrote.

Millennials (born from 1981 through 1996), who range from their late 20s to early 40s, are seen as living in their “sandwich years,” as they juggle raising children and caring for aging parents, which can “greatly influence their ability to save and invest for retirement.”

Meanwhile, members of Generation Z (born from 1997 through 2012) are entering the workforce after enduring a global pandemic and a “tumultuous” labor market. Unlike those in other generations, however, they have a “long time horizon to build and grow their retirement savings,” Collinson wrote.

Gen X, therefore, appears most vulnerable, as members are in their prime earning years but seriously looking at retirement, and many feel they have not saved enough in retirement accounts. That generation has a median total household retirement savings of $82,000, compared with median savings of $289,000 for Baby Boomers, $49,000 for Millennials and $29,000 for Gen Z, according to the research.

“Every generation in the workforce is at risk of not achieving a financially secure retirement. Generation X is especially vulnerable,” according to Collinson. “They can still improve their prospects by setting realistic expectations, engaging in financial planning, and re-envisioning their life course including time in the workforce and retirement.” 

They also called on “policymakers, the private sector, and employers” to strengthen the retirement system for all generations.

“The SECURE 2.0 Act of 2022 has a multitude of provisions that address many issues, but a highly coordinated effort is needed to ensure they are implemented and successful,” according to Collinson. “Moreover, it is time to strengthen Social Security and Medicare and expand these benefits to include long-term care services, affordable housing, and improved financial literacy.”

The nonprofit Transamerica Institute is the parent organization of the Transamerica Center for Retirement Studies. The Transamerica Institute is funded by the Transamerica Life Insurance Company and its affiliates.

Principal Joins Portability Services Network

Consortium now has representation from the country’s five largest plan sponsors.


Principal Financial Group announced it has joined the Portability Services Network LLC, a consortium of retirement plan service providers seeking to help workers with lower balances transfer their workplace retirement accounts when changing employers.

The addition of Principal means the country’s five largest recordkeepers by assets are now part of the network, adding to Fidelity Investments, Empower, Vanguard and Alight Solutions, according to the latest ranking by PLANSPONSOR. After Empower joined in February, TIAA, the country’s largest 403(b) recordkeeper, joined the network in April.

Want the latest retirement plan adviser news and insights? Sign up for PLANADVISER newsletters.

As a board member and one of seven owning members of PSN, Principal will utilize the auto-portability solution developed by Retirement Clearinghouse, according to the announcement Thursday.

“As a retirement leader, it’s our responsibility and commitment to help create the best possible retirement outcomes for America’s workers, including making it easy for their retirement savings to move with them,” Teresa Hassara, Principal’s senior vice president for retirement and income solutions, said in a statement. “Being a part of the Portability Services Network adds another tool to the toolbox we have at Principal to support individuals on their paths to achieving financial security.”

By automating the process, the PSN hopes that workers will be able to transfer their assets into various retirement accounts such as 401(k), 401(a), 403(b) and 457 plans without unnecessary complications. This streamlined approach can reduce premature plan cash-outs and promote financial security, according to PSN.

“[Principal’s] leadership, action, and progress to increase financial access and inclusion will help more people benefit from auto-portability—in particular people of color, lower-income workers, and women, who have higher than average cash-out rates,” Robert Johnson, chairman of PSN and Retirement Clearinghouse, said in a statement.

PSN currently represents about 82 million workers across more than 185,000 employer-sponsored retirement plans. Principal brings an additional 11 million retirement plan participants and more than 46,000 plans to the coalition, according to the announcement.

The network is building a recordkeeper base even as the SECURE 2.0 Act of 2022 called on the Department of Labor to create a centralized retirement account “lost and found” for American workers. The DOL has said it is looking into the best approach to create this database.

«