Advisers Who Successfully Serve the LGBTQ Community

Retirement plan experts say people in this market are in need of advisers who are attuned to and understand their needs.


Growing a retirement plan advisory practice and succession planning are two top-of-mind considerations for advisers. One way to tackle both of those goals and advance a practice while setting the next generation up for success, advocates say, is to embrace members of the LGBTQ community.

One of Northwestern Mutual’s practices serving the LGBTQ community is based in Milwaukee and has grown and thrived for more than a decade, and Brio Benefit Consulting of New York runs a benefits practice that also serves this market. These two practices grew and evolved naturally out of the interests and sensitivities of their leaders and are prime examples of how retirement plan practices can meet the financial needs of specialty groups.

Want the latest retirement plan adviser news and insights? Sign up for PLANADVISER newsletters.

“Brio Benefits works with a number of LGBTQ communities throughout the country, including the LGBTQ Community Center, True Colors United and the Callen-Lorde Community Health Center in New York,” as well as Center Link, which operates in 45 states, Puerto Rico and Washington, D.C., says Matthew Compton, director, retirement services, at Brio Benefits.

The Milwaukee-based Northwestern Mutual LGBTQ advisory practice began when a young adviser, Gina Pagán, who had started with the firm as a college intern, privately told her manager she is a gay Latina. Today, Pagán runs a six-person wealth management practice at Northwestern that focuses on women and LGBTQ people.

“Northwestern has a massive presence in Milwaukee, and I thought, ‘This is something I would want to be a part of,’” she tells PLANADVISER. “I was 20, 21 when I joined, and I was not out. I was not upfront about my lifestyle or my partner. Northwestern Mutual is really the only company and career I have known in my adult life. I am 32. I have grown up here. It certainly has been an evolution. Now I sit on the LGBTQ field advisory committee, and I have a leadership role in our firm.”

Pagán says she is enormously grateful to Northwestern Mutual and her managers for supporting her and helping her to serve the community and attract that clientele.

“The bulk of what I do is on the individual side, so I help manage small business retirement plans,” Pagán says. The key to serving this community, she says, is to let them know that they can ask her authentic questions and not be judged or intimidated.

“Women and people in the queer community have these experiences with other advisers where it is uncomfortable and they don’t feel safe or [receive] comprehensive planning because they couldn’t be totally authentic,” she says. “I want to be that person for other folks in my community.”

“Now I sit on the LGBTQ field advisory committee, and I have a leadership role in our firm.”

Compton adds that now that pandemic restrictions are lifting, it is important for advisers serving this market to provide as much face-to-face education as possible and make sure they meet personally with members of these organizations. Obviously, he adds, it is vital for advisers working with LGBTQ people to be “aware of how they would like to be addressed and recognized. A big part of that is making sure the community knows we recognize their needs.”

Pagán says she is grateful for Northwestern’s open-mindedness toward an array of diverse people. As the number of clients and assets she serves has grown, so, too, has the understanding among Northwestern Mutual’s leadership team of the value that Pagán brings to these clients.

“It was new for them to navigate as well, but always from a place of trying to do it right,” she says. “I have been able to lend my insight, and we have grown together. I am super proud of the progress Northwestern has made, and it has impacted me, personally. I don’t think I would be here if I didn’t think my company valued me as a human, as a person.”

Triple the Clients

Northwestern Mutual has championed efforts to hire and serve a more diverse and inclusive population. Last year, Northwestern hired nearly 50% more female advisers, and, since 2015, diverse advisers overall have grown by 66%. There has also been a 101% growth in diverse field leaders over the same time span.

Since increasing its LGBTQ efforts in 2017, the number of clients Pagán and her team serve has tripled.

When working with any niche demographic market, advisers must be mindful of using inclusive language and be excellent listeners, Pagán says.

Financial planners and retirement plan advisers, for the most part, “are very white, very male and older,” she says. “Over the last year, the movement toward inclusion and diversity and equity has become more important” and is something that retirement plan practices should consider.

“It’s important because the landscape of our country is going to be changing, and the generations coming in behind us are going to be looking different,” Pagán says. “Wealth transfer is going to be different,” so in preparation for this, practices need to seek out more diverse talent and establish a presence in various types of communities.

“It has to be more than just donating or attending an occasional Pride Fest,” she continues. “It’s about making sure we align our actions with our values.”

Being open-minded is key for asset management firms and retirement plan advisers in order to be relevant in the future, Pagán continues. “They also need to work with Millennials and be prepared to answer more questions about ESG [environmental, social and governance] investing.”

Compton concurs that “socially responsible, holistic, inclusive and diverse investing are incredibly important topics” for the LGBTQ community. And it shouldn’t just be advisers who expand their umbrellas to the community. Asset managers and recordkeepers should “demonstrate a culture of diversity and inclusion,” as well, he says.

“The diversity and inclusion piece is going to become even more important as these Millennials start to age,” Pagán says. “If there isn’t any action [taken] upon it, the unfortunate truth is that firms will be left behind.”

Editor’s Note: June is Pride Month.

More Clients Are Using Social Media to Vet Advisers

Hartford Funds data finds that, overall, 33% of respondents reported seeking financial advice online and almost half say social media impacts whom they retain as a financial professional.

Billions of people worldwide have social media accounts, and social media is nearly ubiquitous in the U.S. Meaning that if you’re a financial adviser without a social media presence, you could be losing out on some serious marketing strategies.

Want the latest retirement plan adviser news and insights? Sign up for PLANADVISER newsletters.

A new survey from Wells Fargo & Co. revealed that 35% of surveyed teenagers learned about finances from social media, with 34% using websites and online articles. Separate data from Hartford Funds found that almost one-quarter of Generation Z respondents said they would not hire a financial adviser who doesn’t have a social media presence. In fact, 24% of Gen Zers in the study reported seeking financial advice on social media.

“If you’re going to appeal across generations, having multiple digital presences is important,” says Bill McManus, managing director of applied insights at Hartford Funds. “Especially as we come out of a pandemic, you have to assume the first place anyone will go to find out about your services is your website, Facebook, LinkedIn, Instagram and any other social media account.”

McManus, who works with financial professionals on adapting their strategies in a virtual environment and has worked with the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) Age Lab, explains that a client looks for prospective financial adviser much the same way people look for anything in a digital world.

“If you go to a city that you’ve never been to or if you’re going on a vacation, what’s the first thing you’re going to do when you’re looking for a restaurant? You’re going to go online and look for something that is what you’re seeking based on reviews and engagement,” he explains. “It’s no different now than any other type of service you’re going to seek now, including with financial professionals.”

The Hartford Funds data suggests this desire for online engagement doesn’t stop with younger groups. Findings showed that, overall, 33% of respondents reported seeking financial advice online. Almost half of the people surveyed said social media impacts whom they retain as a financial professional, with 20% of that group noting that social media was their sole deciding factor in the decisionmaking process when evaluating a financial professional. More telling, 64% of respondents said they feel comfortable discussing personal information during a virtual meeting with a financial professional.

Social media has significantly altered how individuals are interacting and what they’re discussing online. Platforms including Instagram, TikTok and now Clubhouse let people delve into an endless number of subjects with content coming from experts, influencers and everyday people alike.

And as more people tuned to their computers and phones throughout 2020 amid lockdowns and social distancing requirements, financial service companies saw this as an opportunity. An eMarketer report found digital ad spending in the U.S. financial services industry grew 9.7% in 2020, up to $19.62 billion.

During the pandemic, 74% of financial advisers who used social media for business initiated new relationships or onboarded new clients, according to the Putnam Investments Social Advisor 2020 Study. Even as the U.S. workforce enters a new recovery phase post-pandemic, advisers can expect these strategies to stay, experts say.

Jeff Mattonelli, a financial adviser who works with Gen Z and Millennial clients at Van Leeuwen & Co., says he’s noticed the impact social media plays in guiding prospective clients. The firm regularly uses Twitter, LinkedIn and Facebook to market content to clients. When the company posted information on 529 savings plans on its Twitter account, a former classmate of Mattonelli’s reached out to him to create an account for his child after seeing the post. “Right there, we were able to generate a lead and prospect just from having posted that type of content,” Mattonelli says.

Building a social media presence can not only increase client numbers, but it can also establish additional credibility, he says. Because information online is wide-ranging and substantial, it is vital for advisers to post consistent and tailored content with a reputable presence. Clients who are searching for or vetting a specific adviser will first go to social media when deciding, Mattonelli says.

“Especially on social media, it’s really important that we’re posting content consistently to show that we have credibility in terms of the different services that we offer,” he explains. “Posting daily lends itself to credibility. It’s important to be on social media, but it’s the presence that you’re building that’s really much more important.”

«